Abstract
How does a social history museum end up obfuscating issues it intends to highlight? How does the Tenement Museum—an institution committed to “challenging the future” by “revealing the past”—come to obscure structural issues related to housing, immigration, and poverty? Through a comparison of participant observation of tours and analysis of institutional archives at the Tenement Museum, I show how decisions made for pragmatic reasons and materialized into domestic spaces obfuscate structural issues, both in the past and the present. Specifically, I demonstrate how the museum advances historic role models and the American Dream through depictions of tenement apartments, thereby displacing the very issues that tenement housing encapsulates. It is not news to sociologists that museums depict selective narratives that reinforce cultural tropes. Nor is it surprising that museums use domestic space as a mnemonic vehicle through which to portray the narratives they select. What is surprising, however, is that this happens in a museum that is invested in challenging the narratives it ends up depicting. Unpacking how this happens is especially pertinent because of the prevalence of museums that depict domestic spaces of the past, given the increased necessity for museums to educate in order to secure funding, and in light of contemporary political debates over housing and immigration.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Although there is a powerful connection between domesticity and the American Dream (see Garb 2005; Spigel 2013), domestic rhetoric is not inherently linked to the American Dream (nor, indeed, to the Tenement Museum). As a rhetorical device, it could be used by other institutions or social actors and in the service of other narratives and ideologies.
Although the accuracy of the term “restored” is questionable, I use this term to mirror how the Tenement Museum describes its exhibits.
Time constraints meant I was unable to visit the fourth tour. Since writing this article, the Tenement Museum has opened a new tour: Shop Life, which focuses on the 1870s German saloon of John and Caroline Schneider in the building’s storefront.
For recent positions, the museum has required researchers and curators to have at least a Master’s degree in related fields (i.e. history, preservation or library science) and two years of relevant experience. For docents, the museum requires a high school diploma or equivalent (Lower East Side Tenement Museum 2015).
Manager of Donor Relations at the Tenement Museum, personal communication.
Though some museums choose to make stories of suffering their focus (see Lennon and Foley 2000), a tenement museum may not be appealing considering the pervasive and long-enduring view of tenements as filthy, disease-riddenan and dangerous.
Tenants left 97 Orchard Street in the 1930s, which was a common trajectory for housing on New York’s Lower East Side. The area saw a rapid construction of tenements for a working-class population of mostly European immigrants in the mid to late 1800s, and then a sharp population decline in the 1930s, when the area’s buildings were largely vacated except for their store fronts (see Mele 2000).
Lower East Side Tenement Museum Conservation Plan: Ruin Apartments, Hallways, Stairs, and Toilets, Jablonski Berkowitz Conservation, Inc. June 8, 2005. Lower East Side Tenement Museum Archives (hereafter LESTM), 2.
Historic Furnishing Report Gumpertz Apartment Recreation, November 5 2003, LESTM.
Restoration and Furnishings of the Baldizzi and Gumpertz Apartments, LESTM.
Historic Furnishing Report Gumpertz Apartment Recreation, November 5 2003, LESTM.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Outline of LESTM Apartment Tours, Draft October 10 1993, LESTM.
Memo: NEH Re-Created Apartments, January 7 1994, LESTM.
Memo: Gumpertz/Baldizzi remaining objects to be purchased and related interpretive issues, LESTM.
Historic Furnishings Report: The Moore-Meehan Family Apartment, 2004, LESTM.
Lower East Side Tenement Museum. Moore Family.
The Moore Family: An Irish Family in America Minutes of the Second Historical Advisors Meeting. August 2 2004. LESTM.
The Moore Family. LESTM.
Historic Furnishings Report: The Moore-Meehan Family Apartment. 2004 LESTM.
The paint analysis suggested that the layers of paint found, which corresponded to the time period just before the Moores moved into the building, were delicate pastel colors, such as pale blue, sea green, and lavender. These colors, as well as the painting technique used, were fashionable among the nineteenth century middle class and promoted by prominent style-arbiters (The Moore-Meehan Family Apartment 2004).
The Moore-Meehan Family Apartment 2004
Restoration and Furnishings of the Baldizzi and Gumpertz Apartments. LESTM.
Josephine Baldizzi Interview 13 October 1995. LESTM.
Outline of LESTM Apartment Tours, Draft 10 October 1993. LESTM.
Notes on the Baldizzi Apartment planning meeting 24 May, 1993. LESTM.
Ibid.
Memo: Josephine’s comments on the apartment, 4 October, 1994. LESTM.
LESTM Restoration Proposal, 27 June, 1994. LESTM.
Memo: Josephine’s comments on the apartment, 4 October, 1994. LESTM.
Notes on the Baldizzi Apartment. LESTM.
Although, at first, the museum’s researchers thought that the Baldizzi family had lived on the second floor of 97 Orchard Street. Josephine Baldizzi’s memories of a wooden cabinet made by her father, however, pointed the researchers to an apartment on the third floor, which Josephine confirmed had indeed been the apartment in which her family had lived.
This may be related to recent scandals about eminent domain and union-busting in which the museum has recently been embroiled (Chan 2008).
References
Abram, Ruth J. 2001. Keynote speech at the national park service and civic engagement workshop. http://www.nps.gov/nero/greatplaces/OpeningKeynote.htm. Accessed 12 June 2014.
Abram, Ruth J. 2005. History is as history does: The evolution of a mission-driven museum. In Looking reality in the eye: Museums and social responsibility, ed. Robert Janes and Gerald Conaty. Calgary: University of Calgary Press.
Banks, Patricia. 2010. Represent: Art and identity among the black upper-middle class. New York: Routledge.
Bartram, Robin. 2016. Housing social and material vulnerabilities. Housing, Theory and Society 33(4): 469–483.
Beaudry, Mary C., and Stephen A. Mrozowski. 2001. Cultural space and worker identity in the company city: Nineteenth-century Lowell, Massachusetts. In The archaeology of urban landscape: Explorations in slumland, ed. Alan Mayne and Tim Murray, 118–131. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bell, Ford W. 2012. How are museums supported financially in the United States? United States Department of State Bureau of International Information Programs. http://photos.state.gov/libraries/amgov/133183/english/P_You_Asked_How_Are_Museums_Supported_Financially.pdf. Accessed 22 May 2016.
Benford, Robert D., and David A. Snow. 2000. Framing processes and social movements: An overview and assessment. Annual Review of Sociology 26: 611–639.
Bennett, Tony. 1995. The birth of the museum: History, theory, politics. London and New York: Routledge.
Bielby, William T., and Denise D. Bielby. 1994. “All hits are flukes:” Institutionalized decision making and the rhetoric of network prime-time program development. American Journal of Sociology. 99(5): 1287–1313.
Boyer, Christine. 1994. The city of collective memory: Its historical imagery and architectural entertainments. Mass: MIT Press.
Brodkin, Karen. 1998. How Jews became white folks and what that says about race in America. New Brunswick and London: Rutgers University Press.
Carbonell, Bettina, ed. 2014. Museum studies: An anthology of contexts. Malden: Blackwell.
Chan, Sewell. 2008. “At Tenement Museum, a fight over unionization” New York Times Blog. http://cityroom.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/03/04/at-tenement-museum-a-fight-over-unionization/?_r=0. Accessed 10 Jan 2016.
Clark, William A.V. 2003. Immigrants and the American dream: Remaking the middle class. New York: Guilford Press.
Contreras, Randol. 2013. The stickup kids: Race, drugs, violence, and the American dream. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly, and Eugene Rochberg-Halton. 1981. The meaning of things: Domestic symbols and the self. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Day, Jared. 1999. Urban castles: Tenement housing and landlord activism in New York City, 1890–1943. New York: Columbia University Press.
Desmond, Matthew. 2016. Evicted: Poverty and profit in the American city. New York: Crown Publishers.
Dolkart, Andrew S. 2007. Biography of a tenement house in New York City. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Domínguez Rubio, Fernando, and Elizabeth Silva. 2013. Materials in the field: Object-trajectories and object-positions in the field of contemporary art. Cultural Sociology 7(2): 161–178.
Douglas, Mary. 2007. Forgotten Knowledge. In Shifting contexts: Transformation in anthropological knowledge, ed. M. Strathern, 13–29. London, UK: Routledge.
Fine, Gary Alan. 2001. Difficult reputations: Collective memories of the evil, inept, and controversial. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Garb, Margaret. 2005. City of American dreams: A history of home ownership and housing reform in Chicago, 1871–1919. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Gieryn, Thomas F. 2002. What buildings do. Theory and Society 31(1): 35–75.
Godart, Frédéric C., and Ashley Mears. 2009. How do cultural producers make creative decisions? Lessons from the catwalk. Social Forces 88(2): 671–692.
Grazian, David. 2003. Blue Chicago: The search for authenticity in urban blues clubs. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Grazian, David. 2008. On the make: The hustle of urban nightlife. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Griswold, Wendy. 1987. A methodological framework for the sociology of culture. Sociological Methodology 17: 1–35.
Griswold, Wendy, Gemma Mangione, and Terence E. McDonnell. 2013. Objects, words, and bodies in space: Bringing materiality into cultural analysis. Qualitative Sociology 36: 343–364.
Halle, David. 1993. Inside culture: Art and class in the American home. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hayden, Delores. 1995. The power of place. Cambridge: The MIT Press.
Hetherington, Kevin. 2011. Foucault, the museum and the diagram. The Sociological Review 59(3): 457–475.
Hewison, Robert. 1987. The heritage industry: Britain in a climate of decline. London: Methuen.
Higginbotham, Evelyn Brooks. 1993. Righteous discontent: The women’s movement in the black Baptist church: 1880–1920. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Hirsch, Paul M. 1986. From ambushes to golden parachutes: Corporate takeovers as an instance of cultural framing and institutional integration. American Journal of Sociology 91: 800–837.
Hochschild, Jennifer L. 1995. Facing up to the American dream: Race, class, and the soul of the nation. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Hurdley, Rachel. 2013. Home, materiality, memory and belonging: Keeping culture. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Ignatiev, Noel. 1995. How the Irish became white. New York: Routledge.
International Coalition for Sites of Conscience. 2016. http://www.sitesofconscience.org/. Accessed 25 May 2016.
Jepperson, Ronald L. 1991. Institutions, institutional effects, and institutionalism. In The new institutionalism in organizational analysis, ed. Walter W. Powell and Paul J. DiMaggio, 143–163. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Jones, Paul, and Suzanne MacLeod. 2016. Museum architecture matters. Museum and Society 14(1): 207–219.
Karp, Ivan. 1992. In Museums and communities: The politics of public culture, eds. Christine Mullen Kreamer and Steven Levineeds. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Press.
Klonk, Charlotte. 2009. Spaces of experience: Art gallery interiors from 1800 to 2000. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
Lennon, John, and Malcolm Foley. 2000. Dark tourism: The attraction of death and disasters. London: Thomson Learning.
Levitt, Peggy. 2015. Artifacts and allegiances: How museums put the nation and the world on display. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Lowenthal, David. 1998. The heritage crusade and the spoils of history. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Lower East Side Tenement Museum. 2005. Moore Family. http://tenement.org/encyclopedia/97_moore.htm. Accessed 11 June 2014.
Lower East Side Tenement Museum. 2008. A tenement story. New York City: Lower East Side Tenement Museum.
Lower East Side Tenement Museum. 2009. Staff/Trustees. https://www.tenement.org/staff.php. Accessed 16 May 2016.
Lower East Side Tenement Museum 2015. Jobs. http://www.tenement.org/jobs.php. Accessed 15 Jan 2015.
Lower East Side Tenement Museum. 2016a. About us. https://www.tenement.org/about.html. Accessed 5 Jan 2016.
Lower East Side Tenement Museum. 2016b. Visit: Tours and tickets. http://www.tenement.org/tours.php. Accessed 5 Jan 2016.
Lower East Side Tenement Museum. 2016c. Our supporters. https://www.tenement.org/support_funders.php. Accessed 16 May 2016.
Lower East Side Tenement Museum. 2016d. Support us. http://www.tenement.org/supportus_home.html. Accessed 14 June 2014.
Love, Heather. 2007. Feeling backward: Loss and the politics of queer history. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Lubove, Roy. 1962. The progressives and the slums: Tenement house reform in New York City, 1890–1917. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Macdonald, Sharon, eds. 1998. The politics of display: Museums, science, culture. London and New York: Routledge.
Macdonald, Sharon. 2002. On “old things:” the fetishization of past everyday life. In British subjects: An anthropology of Britain, ed. Nigel Rapport, 89–106. Oxford: Berg.
MacLeod, Jay. 2009. Ain’t no makin’ it: Aspirations and attainment in a low-income neighborhood (third edition). Boulder: Westview Press.
Meyer, John W., and Brian Rowan. 1977. Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony. American Journal of Sociology 83: 340–363.
Madigan, Ruth, and Moira Munro. 1996. “House beautiful:” Style and consumption in the home. Sociology 30(1): 41–57.
Mele, Christopher. 2000. Selling the lower east side: Culture, real estate, and resistance in New York City. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Miller, Daniel. 1988. Appropriating the state on the council estate. Man 23(2): 353–372.
Miller, Daniel, ed. 2001. Home possessions: Material culture behind closed doors. Oxford: Berg Publishers.
Miller, Daniel. 2008. The comfort of things. Cambridge: Polity.
Milligan, Melinda. 2007. Buildings as history: The place of collective memory in the study of historic preservation. Symbolic Interaction 30(1): 105–123.
National Public Housing Museum. 2015. Place. http://www.nphm.org/our-vision/place/. Accessed 7 Nov 2015.
National Trust for Historic Preservation. 2016. "Shop life:” Exploring the immigrant entrepreneur at the Tenement Museum. http://blog.preservationnation.org/2013/01/02/shop-life-exploring-the-immigrant-entrepreneur-at-the-tenement-museum/#.U1KS5fldVp0. Accessed 12 June 2016.
Ozaki, Ritsuko. 2001. Society and housing form: Home-centredness in England Vs. Family-centredness in Japan. Journal of Historical Sociology 14: 337–357.
Pelak, Cynthia. 2015. Institutionalizing counter-memories of the U.S. civil rights movement: The National Civil Rights Museum and an application of the interest-convergence principle. Sociological Forum 30(2): 305–327.
Peterson, Richard A. 1997. Creating country music: Fabricating authenticity. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Porter, Gaby. 1988. Putting your house in order: Representations of women and domestic life. In The museum time-machine: Putting cultures on display, ed. Robert Lumley, 101–126. London: Routledge.
Pustz, Jennifer. 2010. Voices from the back stairs: Interpreting servants’ lives at historic house museum. De Kalb, IL: Northern Illinois University.
Ram, Uri. 2009. Ways of forgetting: Israel and the obliterated memory of the Palestinian Nakba. Journal of Historical Sociology 22(2): 366–395.
Rhodes, Leara. 2010. The ethnic press: Shaping the American dream. New York: Peter Lang.
Riis, Jacob. 1901. The battle with the slum. New York: Houghton, Mifflin.
Rochberg-Halton, Eugene. 1986. Meaning and modernity: Social theory in the pragmatic attitude. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Roediger, David, and James Barrett. 1997. How white people became white. In Critical white studies: Looking behind the mirror, eds. Richard Delgado and Jean Stefancic, 402–407. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Schwartz, Barry. 2000. Abraham Lincoln and the forge of national memory. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Shackel, Paul. 2009. An archaeology of American labor and working class life. Gainesville: University of Florida Press.
Silliman, Stephen. 2006. Struggling with labor, working on identities. In Historical archaeology, eds. Martin Hall and Stephen Silliman, 147–166. Malden and London: Blackwell Publishing.
Snow, David, et al. 1986. Frame alignment processes, micromobilization and movement participation. American Sociological Review 51: 464–481.
Spigel, Lynn. 2013. Make room for TV: Television and the family ideal in postwar America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Staff of the Institute for Children, Poverty and Homelessness. 2014. Today’s other half. https://www.tenement.org/blog/todays-other-half/. Accessed 5 May 2016
Stansell, Christine. 1986. City of women: Sex and class in New York, 1789–1860. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Steinberg, Adam. 2016. The Rent is due. https://www.tenement.org/blog/the-rent-is-due-a-history-of-rent-at-97-orchard-street/. Accessed 5 May 2016.
Urry, John. 1995. Consuming places. London: Routledge.
Wagner-Pacifici, Robin, and Barry Schwartz. 1991. The Vietnam Veteran’s memorial: Commemorating a difficult past. American Journal of Sociology 97: 376–420.
Woodward, Ian. 2001. Domestic objects and the taste epiphany: A resource for consumption methodology. Journal of Material Culture 6(2): 115–136.
Wright, Patrick. 2009. On living in an old country: The national past in contemporary Britain. New York: Oxford University Press.
Zubrzycki, Geneviève. 2013. Aesthetic revolt and the remaking of national identity in Quebec, 1960-1969. Theory and Society 42(5): 423–475.
Acknowledgements
For comments and suggestions, I thank the editor and reviewers at Qualitative Sociology, Wendy Griswold, Mary Pattillo, Gary Fine, Matthew Johnson, Geneviève Zubrzycki, Melissa Pearson, Kevin Loughran, Jordan Conwell, Vincent Yung, Stefan Vogler, Juliette Galonnier, and Brian Sargent. I also thank archivists at the Tenement Museum.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bartram, R. Housing Historic Role Models and the American Dream: Domestic Rhetoric and Institutional Decision-Making at the Tenement Museum. Qual Sociol 40, 1–22 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11133-016-9349-0
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11133-016-9349-0